Dr. Guttler's Newsletter

July 26, 2004

Hello to all my subscribers,

The American Thyroid Association (ATA), Endocrine Society, and American Association of Clinical Endocrinology (AACE) are disappointed with the FDA. The full force of 3 major societies came out against the FDA's ruling to approve generic T4 as equivalent to the brand name. That is a total of about 5000 clinical endocrinologists represented in those 3 societies. Why? T4 has a narrow toxic to therapeutic ratio. There is significant consequences of excess or inadequate treatment. Adverse effects of the wrong dose include:

  1. Recurrence of symptoms
  2. Osteoporosis
  3. Atrial Fibrillation
  4. Worsening of heart disease
  5. Preterm delivery
  6. High cholesterol

There are 12 strengths of T4. They vary by as little as 9% in T4 content. Close titration is required for optimal therapy.

13 Million Americans are on Thyroid Medication

They all are at Risk!
Incorrect dosing can effect the elderly, pregnant women, the fetus, and thyroid cancer patients the most.

Now, the patient and physician may not know the patient was switched off the brand before an adverse event occurs.

Previously in my newsletters, I have spelled out why the FDA is wrong about generics due to faulty methods to determine bioequivalence. All 3 societies urged further studies to answer serious defects. Well, the FDA, after giving us lip service, made the decision without our expert advice and consent.

What should you do now?

  1. Be aware of planned aggressive switching at your drug store. They will tell you generics are equal.
    Do not believe them.
  2. Demand a "do not substitute" Rx from your physician.
  3. If you let them switch you, they you will need a retesting on the new generic.
  4. This should make you mad, and cost you more money. If you stayed on the brand, you would not need another test.

A proper Brand only RX should be written to prevent the drug store from substituting a generic on you.

  1. Have your physician write: "Synthroid", "brand only", "void if substituted"
  2. Physician must initial the brand only line.
  3. Then it is up to you to make sure the drug store does not slip you a generic.
  4. They are not allowed to give you a generic when you have the above RX!
  5. Tell them 5000 Endocrinologist disagree with the FDA on T4 generics.

Yours truly, and goodbye,

Richard Guttler M.D., F.A.C.E.
The "Doctor Reporter" for
The Thyroid Home Page:
www.thyroid.com founded in 1997.
25 Million Hits/year - 600,000 visitors/year
Sole Thyroid Physician:
Santa Monica Thyroid Center, Founded in 1974
Clinical Professor of Medicine:
USC/Keck School of Medicine - 1974-present

"You are the thyroid patients.......
I am the thyroid doctor"

Thyroid Disease Opinions from the desk of
Richard Guttler M.D., F.A.C.E.

The Thyroid Home Page does not receive any outside funding of any sort, and especially none from Abbott, (Synthroid), Jones, (Levoxyl) or any other thyroid drug companies. (Unithroid, Levothyroid, or Armour). No other top ten thyroid web site can make that claim.

 

 

MORE THYROID INFORMATION...

The Latest in Thyroid Cancer Therapy. More...

A Road Map to insure that you get good medical care for your thyroid cancer

What is a Thyroidologist and why do I want to consult with one? Click to find a Thyroidologist

Join Dr. Guttler's Thyroid Newsletter

PEI for Thyroid Cysts - Percutaneous Ethanol Injection

Small Papillary Thyroid Cancer < 10 mm
Does Total Thyroidectomy and Radioiodine Ablation
Save Lives or Decrease Recurrence Rates?

PEI for Thyroid Cancer Lymph Nodes

Two Cancer Surgeries and now another recurrence.
What should you do?

Pre-Operative Ultrasound Lymph Node Mapping BEFORE the Cancer Surgery. Ask for it. It can save you a second surgery later.

Role of lymph node dissection in primary surgery for thyroid cancer.

Get a Second Opinion

Ask the Doctor

New Therapy for Graves' Hyperthyroid Patients with Active Thyroid Eye Disease

Women over 35 need to be screened for thyroid disease

New Non Surgical therapy for Nodular Goiter

Parathyroid Adenoma and High Serum Calcium: Exploratory or Minimally Invasive Surgery?